The Desk///Case overviewShould we increase Northstar after results?
Demo data. Northstar is a fictional company. Figures come from the calculation engine.
Should we increase Northstar after results?
Entry price
£30.00 · 29 Oct 2026Fictional reference price
Horizon
3 years
Hurdle
12% a yearannualised price return, excluding dividends
Decision owner
William Harris
Review status
Revision 1: William Harris decided to holdRevision 2: draft opened after the 6 Nov 2026 observation
7.42 pp apart, from 5.00 pp of operating margin
Emma BennettAssumes operating margin of 27.00%
William HarrisAssumes operating margin of 22.00%
0%4%8%12%16%12% hurdle
Q-01: How much of the margin improvement persists once freight and energy relief unwinds? Look for underlying margin in the results statement and segment note.
Margin gap
5.00 pp
Return gap
7.42 pp
Hurdle
12.00%
Boundary margin
26.67%
Open items
Each judgement stays attributed to the person who made it.
Scenarios against the 12% hurdle
Select a bar for its calculation
-5%05%10%15%20%
The Pitch
What exactly are we deciding?
Action under consideration
Should we increase Northstar after results?
Position size and portfolio weight are outside the scope of this review.
Decision owner
William Harris
Participant views
William Harris · Emma Bennett
Information cutoff
2026-11-06
Horizon
3 years
Hurdle
12.00% p.a., price only
Reference price
£30.00 GBP
Circle of Competence
Which businesses do we understand well enough?
Northstar is inside the circle. The circle is the set of businesses the team understands well enough to judge. Cases are opened only for companies inside it.